Create one common scenario
Give every supplier the same machine requirement, site address, start window, duration and expected hours. State whether you need an operator and which attachments are essential. Keep quotes for different scopes in separate columns until the differences are resolved. A cheaper offer is not directly comparable if it excludes the attachment that makes the machine useful.
Separate fixed and usage costs
List delivery, collection and setup once, then record hire, operator and usage-based charges against the relevant period. Ask whether quoted prices include GST. Capture minimum hours, weekend treatment, overtime and excess usage in plain language. This makes short and long hire options easier to compare without disguising fixed costs inside an averaged daily rate.
Run an illustrative comparison
Suppose one hypothetical offer is $300 per day plus $400 return transport, while another is $350 per day plus $150 transport. For two days, those stated items total $1,000 and $850 respectively, before any other charges. These are invented arithmetic examples, not market prices. Their purpose is to show why transport changes the comparison, especially on short hires.
Resolve the exit conditions
Ask when hire charging stops, how off-hire is acknowledged and who arranges collection. Record cleaning, fuel and damage assessment arrangements. Add a separate uncertainty list for anything not yet priced. Do not insert zero for an unanswered item; mark it as awaiting confirmation so the comparison remains honest.
- Align the scope
- Add known costs
- Resolve blanks
Put the decision into practice
Consider two invented five-day quotes on the same tax basis. A lists $300 per day plus $250 delivery and $250 collection: $2,000 before other charges. B lists $340 per day plus $100 delivery and $100 collection: $1,900. The higher daily rate is cheaper on these known lines. If B has not supplied an attachment charge, however, $1,900 is a known subtotal rather than a final comparable price. The next action is to resolve that missing line, not label B the winner. The comparison tool keeps blanks visible for exactly this reason. These figures illustrate arithmetic and are not market rates or a quotation.
| Situation | Check this | Avoid relying on |
|---|---|---|
| Different daily rates | Same duration and scope | Ranking by day rate |
| Blank cost line | Written inclusion or price | Treating blank as free |
| Different billing rules | Equivalent chargeable period | Calendar days automatically billed |
A mistake to avoid
A neat total can hide incompatible assumptions. First align machine, attachments, duration, operating allowance and tax basis. Then record exclusions and unresolved items alongside the subtotal so they cannot disappear in a spreadsheet.
Example enquiry wording
Please quote the attached scope for [chargeable period]. Show hire, attachments, delivery, collection, operator, fuel and other fees separately. State the tax basis, minimum period, operating allowance, exclusions and quote validity. Please mark included items explicitly.Build and download your enquiry →
Include these in your enquiry
- One common scope
- Transport in both directions
- Hours, minimums and GST basis
- Off-hire and return condition
Use these prompts to prepare a discussion. Confirm the actual equipment, site requirements and commercial terms with your supplier and the people responsible for the work.
Practical answers before you hire
Should I compare weekly rates by dividing by seven?
Only if the included hours and charging conditions match. Confirm how weekends, excess usage and early returns are treated before converting rates.
Should an included cost be entered as zero?
Yes, if the quote explicitly includes it. Leave an unknown blank so it stays visible as unresolved.
Can quotes with different tax bases be compared?
First ask for a consistent basis. The tool labels the basis and does not infer or calculate tax.
What about weekly rates?
Convert the actual quoted billing arrangement into an agreed comparable period; do not assume a weekly rate equals seven daily rates.
Sources and editorial method
How AI assistance, sources and editorial examples are used · Report a correction
Prepared by Machinery Hire Directory. Source checked 24 September 2026. Scenarios, comparison prompts and enquiry examples are original editorial illustrations; they are not reports of completed projects or supplier quotations.
Kennards Hire — an example of supplier hire conditions ↗
The linked source provides background. Supplier terms apply to that supplier, and model guidance does not replace the applicable local requirements or equipment documentation. No independent technical reviewer is claimed.