Return to the original requirement
Keep the original output, access, capacity, attachment and programme requirements beside the alternative proposal. Ask why the substitution is being offered and which details change. The relevant question is whether the replacement meets the task, not whether its model name sounds similar. Preserve the original offer so the decision remains traceable.
Compare the working and transport envelope
Request the alternative model's dimensions and relevant operating information. Recheck access, unloading and the intended working position. A change in weight or footprint may affect transport or the site's assessment of suitability. Have the responsible people review the differences rather than assuming the original access approval transfers automatically.
Reconfirm attachments and operating arrangements
Ask whether the same attachments, accessories and operator arrangement are included. Verify compatibility for the revised combination. If an operator changes, confirm site induction and familiarisation arrangements. Record any different fuel, charging or service requirements that the site must accommodate before arrival.
Approve the commercial change explicitly
Confirm the rate, transport, hire period and any revised minimums in writing. Identify who is authorised to accept the alternative and when they did so. Send the final approved details to the receiving team. If the proposal cannot be assessed in time, ask the supplier for another option rather than letting dispatch become the approval mechanism.
- Describe the task
- Check constraints
- Confirm model
Put the decision into practice
The booked machine becomes unavailable the day before delivery. The supplier offers another machine in the same general class. The project team checks its travel dimensions against the gate, confirms the attachment combination and asks whether transport or operating costs change. A tighter tail-swing requirement turns out to be the controlling feature, so the team requests a different option rather than accepting on weight class alone. The approved substitute is then recorded in the booking with the revised documents. This preserves the original task requirements while allowing a practical alternative where it actually fits.
| Situation | Check this | Avoid relying on |
|---|---|---|
| Same nominal class | Task and dimensional requirements | Automatic equivalence |
| Changed attachment | Approved complete combination | Assuming existing setup fits |
| Changed supplier | Terms, support and contacts | Keeping outdated paperwork |
A mistake to avoid
A verbal approval without the replacement model or changed terms leaves the delivery team with little to check. Keep a short written comparison and identify who can approve the change.
Example enquiry wording
Please identify the proposed substitute and compare it with our required dimensions, output and attachments. State changes to price, transport, support or operating conditions. Dispatch should follow written approval by [responsible contact].Build and download your enquiry →
Include these in your enquiry
- Original task requirements
- Alternative model and dimensions
- Attachment and operator changes
- Written price and approval
Use these prompts to prepare a discussion. Confirm the actual equipment, site requirements and commercial terms with your supplier and the people responsible for the work.
Practical answers before you hire
Is a larger substitute automatically acceptable?
No. Extra capacity may come with different dimensions, transport needs or operating constraints. Assess the complete arrangement before accepting it.
Is the same weight class sufficient?
No. Compare the requirements that matter to the task, including dimensions, reach, attachments and operating limits.
Can a substitute change the hire price?
It may. Request the complete revised commercial arrangement before accepting rather than assuming the original price applies.
Who should approve a substitution?
Nominate a person with authority to check the task and commercial requirements, with technical input where needed.
Sources and editorial method
How AI assistance, sources and editorial examples are used · Report a correction
Prepared by Machinery Hire Directory. Source checked 24 September 2026. Scenarios, comparison prompts and enquiry examples are original editorial illustrations; they are not reports of completed projects or supplier quotations.
Safe Work Australia — plant and machinery ↗
The linked source provides background. Supplier terms apply to that supplier, and model guidance does not replace the applicable local requirements or equipment documentation. No independent technical reviewer is claimed.